IowaHawkBlog's Marble Game through Week 4

Welcome everyone, to the 2023 edition of IowaHawkBlog's College Football Marble Game.  For those unfamiliar with the Marble Game, David Burge came up with this idea years ago as a simple ranking system that could be explained in one tweet and that anyone could replicate themselves. The rules have changed slightly over the years, but the basic idea has always been the same. 

The rules of the Marble Game for 2023:
- Each FBS team starts with 100 marbles + 10 bonus marbles for each Power-5 opponent on their schedule.  This leads to teams having between 100 and 220 marbles to start the season.
- For each home win you take 20% of your opponents marbles.
- For each road win you take 25% of your opponents marbles.

- Neutral site games are treated like home games (worth 20%) for each team.
- Fractional marbles get rounded to whole marbles at the time when they are moved from one team to the other.

It is still a little early in the season, so the below results are still slightly un-intuitive, but within about one or two more weeks it will all sort itself out. 

I think I got everything set up for this season correctly (new teams, conference changes, initial marble counts, etc) but by all means, if you see any mistakes in anything, including games completed so far, please message me on Twitter (@NateEMiller). Also, I'm sure David (@IowaHawkBlog) would love to discuss any of this with anyone. 

Also, big shout-out to Jim Carson (@JamesHCarson) for putting together the initial marble counts for this season.  It takes a long time to go through every teams' schedule and count up their opponents.  You saved me hours of work Jim.

EDIT: @CalumetCodger caught where I had missed a neutral site game, and this led me to realize that I'd missed a couple.  So I've made the fixes and updated the list below.  This fix affects UNC, S. Carolina, Louisville, GT, and a few other teams that played those teams in subsequent weeks.  Sorry for the mistake and thanks for looking out for us Calumet Dude!


TeamWLConfMarblesChange
1Penn State 4 0 B10 346 +9,+59
2N. Carolina 4 0 ACC 344 -1,+30
3Florida St. 4 0 ACC 339 +3,+43
4Wash. 4 0 PAC 339 0,+35
5Texas 4 0 B12 338 -2,+28
6Utah 4 0 PAC 338 +3,+50
7Ohio State 4 0 B10 337 +10,+71
8Wash. St. 4 0 PAC 321 +7,+47
9Kansas 4 0 B12 319 +11,+55
10Oregon 4 0 PAC 318 +13,+62
11Michigan 4 0 B10 316 +13,+61
12Oklahoma 4 0 B12 312 +6,+47
13USC 4 0 PAC 311 -2,+28
14Louisville 4 0 ACC 308 -6,+20
15Syracuse 4 0 ACC 296 +1,+27
16Maryland 4 0 B10 290 +11,+42
17Miami (FL) 4 0 ACC 285 +5,+29
18Missouri 4 0 SEC 283 +7,+30
19Duke 4 0 ACC 280 0,+16
20Kentucky 4 0 SEC 268 +12,+35
21Georgia 4 0 SEC 254 +8,+13
22Texas A&M 3 1 SEC 254 +16,+55
23Colorado 3 1 PAC 248 -21,-62
24Wisconsin 3 1 B10 244 +13,+40
25Rutgers 3 1 B10 242 -20,-61
26LSU 3 1 SEC 241 +8,+31
27Iowa 3 1 B10 234 -20,-59
28Alabama 3 1 SEC 233 +17,+51
29Fresno St. 4 0 MWC 226 +4,+15
30Kansas St. 3 1 B12 226 +16,+48
31Auburn 3 1 SEC 222 -18,-55
32W. Virginia 3 1 B12 222 +7,+24
33BYU 3 1 B12 221 -19,-55
34Florida 3 1 SEC 220 +2,+14
35TCU 3 1 B12 216 +5,+23
36Notre Dame 4 1 IND 211 -24,-71
37Arizona 3 1 PAC 208 +11,+33
38Tennessee 3 1 SEC 203 +6,+19
39Ole Miss 3 1 SEC 202 -13,-51
40UCLA 3 1 PAC 198 -12,-50
41Wake Forest 3 1 ACC 197 -20,-66
42James Madison 4 0 SUN 190 +7,+18
43UCF 3 1 B12 190 -13,-48
44Miami (OH) 3 1 MID 189 -3,0
45Liberty 4 0 USA 188 +11,+31
46Oregon St. 3 1 PAC 188 -15,-47
47Georgia Tech 2 2 ACC 186 +31,+66
48NC State 3 1 ACC 185 +5,+24
49Northwestern 2 2 B10 185 +13,+42
50Georgia St. 4 0 SUN 184 +7,+29
51Marshall 3 0 SUN 169 +13,+27
52Nebraska 2 2 B10 169 +6,+16
53Minnesota 2 2 B10 168 -18,-42
54Ohio 4 1 MID 167 +7,+19
55S. Carolina 2 2 SEC 162 +18,+34
56Air Force 4 0 MWC 157 +7,+15
57Iowa State 2 2 B12 157 +22,+37
58Oklahoma St. 2 2 B12 150 -15,-37
59Wyoming 3 1 MWC 148 +16,+20
60Illinois 2 2 B10 147 +9,+14
61UNLV 3 1 MWC 147 +9,+16
62Houston 2 2 B12 142 +10,+14
63California 2 2 PAC 141 -16,-35
64Cincinnati 2 2 B12 140 -22,-47
65Texas State 3 1 SUN 140 +9,+12
66Miss. St. 2 2 SEC 138 -16,-34
67Jacksonville St. 3 1 USA 128 +23,+21
68Clemson 2 2 ACC 127 -17,-43
69Indiana 2 2 B10 127 +19,+15
70Arkansas 2 2 SEC 126 -15,-31
71Georgia So. 3 1 SUN 125 +21,+19
72Mich. St. 2 2 B10 124 -20,-42
73Tulane 3 1 AAC 123 +4,0
74UL Lafayette 3 1 SUN 120 +15,+10
75Purdue 1 3 B10 120 -21,-40
76Toledo 3 1 MID 119 +18,+17
77Memphis 3 1 AAC 118 -17,-30
78UL Monroe 2 1 SUN 117 +4,0
79S. Alabama 2 2 SUN 113 -20,-38
80Rice 2 2 USA 111 -15,-28
81Army 2 2 IND 109 -14,-27
82C. Mich. 2 2 MID 108 +36,+38
83Virginia Tech 1 3 ACC 107 -15,-27
84Vanderbilt 2 3 SEC 103 -18,-35
85Stanford 1 3 PAC 97 -14,-33
86Tulsa 2 2 AAC 97 +31,+25
87Texas Tech 1 3 B12 96 -6,-24
88Florida Int. 3 2 USA 94 -12,-31
89SMU 2 2 AAC 94 -6,-23
90S. Florida 2 2 AAC 94 +33,+28
91Boise State 2 2 MWC 93 +20,+21
92North Texas 1 2 USA 93 +8,0
93Colorado St. 1 2 MWC 91 +20,+19
94Pittsburgh 1 3 ACC 90 -14,-30
95Old Dominion 2 2 SUN 88 +7,0
96Troy 2 2 SUN 87 +28,+21
97Coastal Caro. 2 2 SUN 86 -13,-29
98Temple 2 2 AAC 86 -13,-29
99E. Mich. 2 2 MID 85 -8,-21
100W. Kentucky 2 2 USA 85 -7,-21
101Arizona St. 1 3 PAC 84 -15,-28
102Baylor 1 3 B12 84 -15,-28
103New Mexico 2 2 MWC 84 +19,+18
104App. St. 2 2 SUN 81 -9,-20
105BC 1 3 ACC 81 -9,-20
106Arkansas St. 2 2 SUN 80 +15,+14
107Hawaii 2 3 MWC 80 +21,+18
108UTSA 1 3 USA 77 -10,-19
109N. Illinois 1 3 MID 74 -12,-25
110Virginia 0 4 ACC 72 -11,-24
111NM St. 2 3 USA 70 -10,-18
112W. Michigan 1 3 MID 66 -8,-17
113Navy 1 2 AAC 64 +13,0
114San Diego St. 2 3 MWC 64 -11,-21
115LA Tech 2 3 USA 63 -10,-16
116Akron 1 3 MID 62 -10,-15
117Kent State 1 3 MID 62 -8,-15
118Ball State 1 3 MID 58 -11,-19
119Bowling Grn 1 3 MID 58 -11,-19
120Charlotte 1 3 USA 58 -8,-14
121Florida Atl. 1 3 USA 58 -7,-14
122Mid. Tenn. 1 3 USA 58 -12,-19
123Sam Houston 0 3 USA 58 -8,-14
124S. Miss. 1 3 SUN 58 -8,-14
125E. Carolina 1 3 AAC 53 +7,0
126UAB 1 3 USA 53 -1,-13
127UMASS 1 4 IND 52 -8,-18
128Utah State 1 3 MWC 52 -8,-18
129Connecticut 0 4 IND 47 -2,-16
130Nevada 0 4 MWC 46 0,-12
131UTEP 1 4 USA 46 -2,-16
132San Jose St. 1 4 MWC 43 -1,-15
133Buffalo 0 4 MID 39 0,-10


Average rank of all opponents played per team:
Virginia 36.0
Purdue 37.8
Colorado 47.5
Sam Houston 50.3
Minnesota 50.5
Colorado St. 51.0
Connecticut 51.3
Illinois 51.8
Baylor 52.5
Nevada 55.3
: :
: :
USC 112.0
Liberty 112.8
Kentucky 113.0
Marshall 114.0
Jacksonville St. 115.3
James Madison 117.0
Texas State 118.5
Georgia St. 120.0
UL Lafayette 122.0
Air Force 129.3


Average rank of all teams per conference:
PAC 36.3
B10 38.6
SEC 39.4
B12 44.9
ACC 47.6
SUN 80.9
MWC 91.9
IND 93.3
AAC 93.9
MID 98.3
USA 103.3


Average rank of all opponents played per conference:
B10 67.5
IND 72.4
ACC 75.4
B12 77.0
SEC 78.5
AAC 80.2
PAC 80.2
MWC 81.2
MID 81.5
USA 82.0
SUN 95.4

Comments

Post a Comment